How does ethics shape the way we understand and respond to the defining challenges of our time? For Global Ethics Day 2026, experts from across disciplines convened to examine what it means to re-center ethics in a fragmented and rapidly changing world at Carnegie Council's flagship event, attended virtually by people from 69 different countries.
The discussion spanned finance and governance, climate change, the impact of emerging technologies, and more. How do different sectors weigh questions of responsibility, accountability, and judgment?
BRIAN MATEO: Good morning from Carnegie Council’s Global Ethics Hub in New York City, and welcome to our 13th annual Global Ethics Day Event: "Re-centering Ethics: Finding a Path Forward in a Fragmented World." My name is Brian Mateo, and I serve as director of education and special projects here at Carnegie Council. Today individuals from over 60 countries are hosting their own events or have joined us on our livestream to consider the question, how can we re-center ethics in a fragmented and rapidly changing world?
Ethics is everywhere. It is present in the choices we make every day, from where we choose to shop to what we expect from ourselves and others. It is the discipline of pausing, asking questions, and seeking clarity before making important decisions. Ethics helps us explore a set of standards for what is acceptable and what is not. We see this in our households, our schools’ codes of conduct, and our place of employment. When there are conflicting values, guiding principles help us re-center the conversation and find a path forward.
However, ethics is not just about compliance. It is also a way to examine where our tension comes from, test our assumptions against principles we share, and remain engaged to find solutions. With recent global and technological developments it may seem that ethics is not central to the conversation. Seeing more people recognize when ethics is absent should give us hope. It means that we still understand its importance.
Our task now is to bring ethics back to the center of everyday life. I encourage each of us to revisit Socrates’ enduring question: “How ought we live,” and begin putting those values into action.
At Carnegie Council our commitment to international cooperation, democracy, fidelity, and humanitarianism guides our work. Even at times when these principles are tested, we continue to engage in a good-faith effort to convene individuals, publish, and educate the public on emerging ethical issues.
Today’s multi-sector panel will help us think through ways to re-center ethics in finance and governance, climate change, the impact of emergent technologies, and beyond. Please join me in welcoming our moderator, Asha Rangappa, senior lecturer at the Jackson School of Global Affairs at Yale University; and our speakers, JC de Swaan, lecturer, Economics Department at Princeton University and partner, Cornwall Capital; Kat Duffy, senior fellow for digital and cyberspace policy at the Council on Foreign Relations; and Samira Saddique, director of strategic initiatives at the Center for Earth Ethics.
After today’s event we will post the panel discussion on our website. I encourage all of you to visit our site for additional resources on these topics.
I will now pass the microphone over to Asha.
ASHA RANGAPPA: Thank you. All of you are from different arenas, so I think to contextualize the discussion on re-centering ethics I want to ask each of you a question, which assumes that something pushed ethics aside in each of your arenas. In your field, what pushed it out and when did you first notice it?
JC DE SWAAN: In finance, ethical norms have been eroding for years because of structural factors. Starting in the 1970s you saw major shifts. All the large financial institutions used to be private partnerships and became publicly listed companies. At that time, you started seeing an overwhelming focus on shareholder returns as their guiding principle. That changed behaviors for the next few decades.
The pivot, the real milestone in my mind, was the global financial crisis in 2008 because that is when people realized that there was something off. I would say the assumption part of that was: one, that finance is a force for good in society, which I absolutely believe in; and, two, that more finance is better for the economy and for society.
That is the thing that people started questioning because part of that in academic research was focused on showing the positive linkages between finance, the economy, and society, and then we have this massive financial crisis in 2008. That was a soul-searching moment for finance practitioners but also for people in academia. Then we pivoted toward trying to understand what are the limits of finance. For me, that was the important moment.
Anecdotally, I have been teaching undergraduates for 20 years. Twenty years ago, when my students went into finance it was very rare that they would go into a quantitative role, and now it is no longer a niche. It is overwhelming. A lot of them are going into quantitative roles in finance. My sense is that that quantitative approach, which has a lot of merit, also creates a big buffer between finance professionals and their understanding of their impact on society.
SAMIRA SIDDIQUE: This is such a great question, Asha. Thank you for asking it.
I was reflecting on it last night, thinking about when ethics was ever de-centered from the climate field, and my first thought was, When was it ever part of the field?
There are a few different entryways and inflection points to think about. For climate change as a field, when did climate science come to be, but going back even further and looking at the field more broadly of environmental science and environmental studies. For me, the question is, When did the rupture between humans and nature really occur? We can go all the way back to the rise of empire, colonialism, the beginning of resource extraction from colonies around the world, and this idea that Earth’s resources are things for us to use as the human species. That could have started thousands of years ago.
When we look at climate science as a field, all of the first climate research was started by the fossil fuel industry early in the 1940s or 1950s, and they actually knew that fossil fuel extraction was leading to a rise of greenhouse gas emissions very early on and did not share that research with the wider scientific community or society. For me, in the climate field that is probably one of the first anti-ethical inflection points: We had this knowledge very early on from arguably the main driver of greenhouse gas emissions and they did not share that information.
More recently I would say with the rise of climate science within academia in the 1970s and 1980s there was this overpopulation model within traditional ecology, which basically argued that the overpopulation of humans was leading to overextraction of resources, but in my own understanding, research, fieldwork, and all of this, which was largely based on the Global South, that theory within itself, which was so prized within academia and people who were pro-science and pro-climate change, was still valuing human lives in very unequal ways.
A lot of the overpopulation was happening in Global South countries that were actually on the frontlines of climate change, so arguing that they are the ones who need to change their behaviors when they are the ones least responsible for climate change for me is also an inflection point, even within academia. We see those kinds of disparities in the way we understand who should be responsible for the climate and where that accountability actually lies.
I would say we are very far from having the right ethical debates in the climate world, and there are always different pathways that have led us here to not really think about it enough.
ASHA RANGAPPA: Thank you. Kat?
KAT DUFFY: It is great to be here. It is great to see everyone. I wish I could see everyone who is online as well.
With artificial intelligence (AI) the first and most important thing is to clarify what it is we are talking about because it is a very big term that can mean a lot of different things to a lot of different people. I find in many conversations when people are asking about or thinking about AI they are thinking about one very specific type of artificial intelligence, which is the use of large language models (LLMs)or potentially multimodal models to have consumer-facing or enterprise-facing applications.
Think of water. Water is lakes, rivers, rain, our atmosphere, and 60-80 percent of our bodies. If AI is water, this is a chatbot.
I first want to set the stage that, depending on who you are talking to in AI, it is a very confusing type of question because the ethics of this glass of water and the ethics when I think about the ocean or about rivers are in many ways very different, but I am going to want them all to be clean. Ideally, I would want them to be equitably distributed.
I have no idea where this water came from. Some very, very nice individual at Carnegie put it here for me to drink. I am going to assume it is potable and safe. If not, it may be a rough day, but there is an underlying foundation of trust that I have that this water that was put here is safe for me to drink and will be refreshing and nice.
I think in AI it is less about ethics having been de-centered because as an academic field there is a long ethical history of peer review and rigorous scientific and evidence-based development, so if you are talking to an AI researcher, those are the ethics that are going to be front and center, the academic ethics of it. If you are talking to a startup, they are going to be potentially far less focused on the ethics of the entire AI stack because what they are trying to think about is the ends of one beneficial purpose that they are trying to build on top of a whole bunch of things that may be ethically questionable. Asha, you have written a lot about this in terms of thinking about complicity in these broader ecosystems.
I think it is less about ethics being de-centered because ethics is too big a construct and AI is too big a concept. What I think we have is a complete lack of societal agreement on which ethics should apply, which should be prioritized, and what framework we want to base decisions on. The lack of that means that we do not understand where accountability sits, so with AI at the moment I find it more constructive to talk about accountability than to talk about ethics because accountability is a more all-purpose construct for what is essentially an all-purpose technology.
ASHA RANGAPPA: I am so glad that you ended on that note because that is exactly where I want to pick up because that question of accountability also lands very differently in each of your fields.
Samira, I will start with you. In climate the issue is a diffusion of responsibility. All of us contribute to the problem in our own small way, but the harm feels very distant from us. We are not seeing the impact of it. As you noted, for example, in talking about the Global South and overpopulation, it is always easy to point the finger at someone else.
When it comes to climate, how do we get people to feel responsible and institutions to feel that they are accountable for the harms that are being done because I think it is just easy to push it off to somebody else?
SAMIRA SIDDIQUE: I think there are different kinds of responsibility, individuals versus institutions, and what sorts of institutions are you talking about? Will each feel a different sort of responsibility or have to have a different accountability for what we are seeing in climate?
I would also push back against the idea that climate is this distant issue because just in the past few years we are seeing wildfire smoke in New York City. That is not supposed to happen, but it is going to happen more and more because there are wildfires in the Midwest and Canada, and the way that the winds blow it comes over here, so we are dealing with it here. We are seeing more flash-flooding incidents here. I cannot even understand my weather app these days because it just will not tell me, and I always have to carry around an umbrella, and that will not be enough.
I would say that we are seeing even in these Global North countries, the United States, especially on the East Coast, we have not had to deal with wildfires and earthquakes. That was always a California thing, but it is here.
Then we have environmental justice frontline communities in New York City, Brownsville, and Coney Island, that have been dealing with these things for a long time. We may not hear about it in Manhattan, but it is very much here, and there are communities that do think about climate change now because the information is there and is more widespread.
We also see that there are higher numbers of young people especially dealing with climate grief and climate anxiety. There are recent immigrants who come here who have had to flee from climate change and are climate-displaced people, but we only think of them as economic migrants, but they also feel this very intense loss of home, and I think many people are feeling that and a sense of hopelessness and responsibility for their loved ones and communities. That is an intense personal rupture and responsibility that I think we are all dealing with, though we do not talk about it enough.
That is on a personal level, and it ultimately goes back to our connections with ourselves, other people, and other species and living things. To reckon with that a lot of our work at the Center for Earth Ethics is trying to move toward what it means to have this kind of sacred pause in our lives which is very anti how we work in our day-to-day. We just do not have these moments to sit outside and feel the breeze.
That sounds probably like a very small thing, but having these moments to reconnect with our inner awareness is very powerful on an individual level that ripples out. That is more on the spiritual side of things, but that is what we do at the Center for Earth Ethics.
At the institutional responsibility level, I always go back to the fossil fuel industry. It needs to be held to account for all the harms that have come out of that resource extraction and depletion, which affects frontline communities all around the world and has for many decades.
That is what I will say. I do not want to go on for too long, but I will say that climate is not so distant anymore, just to go back to your original question.
ASHA RANGAPPA: I think it is a fair point to think about the actual connection they have to both the environment and the effects of what they are doing.
Kat, AI presents this in a slightly different form, which is not a diffusion of responsibility but a displacement of responsibility. The model is giving outputs. We see this, for example, in the debate over fully autonomous lethal weapons. Where does the moral responsibility lie if the decision making is outsourced to this artificial intelligence? Is this a way of morality laundering?
I think in the legal world this presents big problems. Who is actually liable for causing the harm if there is no mental state you can attribute to any one person, but I wonder how you think about this as the locus of moral responsibility when it comes to AI models and the decisions they make that are then acted upon.
KAT DUFFY: The key term there is “diffusion.” What AI, and particularly the widespread application of LLMs, excels at more than anything is speed and scale. Where you have fissures, open questions, and systemic inequity—and this has been true with many technologies—you have to look at the society, the ecosystem, the ethical framework, or whatever it might be that you are laying the technology on top of, and then think to yourself, What is this going to speed and scale?
We have litigated the law of war. We have the Geneva Conventions, international law, treaties, climate change agreements, and a history—long ago—of a more socially accountable corporate culture I would say than we do now.
Here is the question for me: What will AI speed and what will AI scale? In my experience, and I have been doing this for about 25 years, in these types of societal-facing technologies speed and scale breakage and damage far faster than they can scale anything else, and when you ignore whatever that damage might be and you do not course-correct for it in the design of the technology or in the application of the technology from the outset, you are, I would say, in your framework complicit then in the speeding and scaling of whatever that rupturing might be.
For example, we have had 20 years to figure out how to incorporate cyberattacks into the law of war and into accountability in humanitarian law, and it is still totally unclear how that would be done. This is also part of the challenge, that a lot of how we come to questions of morality comes through deliberative questions and answers that we come to as societies. It is not a fiat. This technology is moving so quickly that it has overcome almost all space for deliberative consensus and evolution.
I tend to spend a lot of my time telling people, “It’s not all new! It’s not all new!” I think what it does do is require us to return to the fundamentals of what we were trying to protect and what we were trying to build laws against, and what we were trying to prevent, look at that foundation, and then leapfrog up and ask, “Okay, how do we reverse-engineer back to that core?”
It is deeply challenging, but this is where we get back to use cases. The ethics of human rights and the ethics of the law of war have alignment at their core in some aspects of humanitarian law and I think any of those practitioners would feel that they sharply diverge as well, so at some point you are making a determination about what your priority there is going to be.
With something like autonomous weapons, there is a world in which that feels like a zero-accountability structure. There is also a world in which completely autonomous weapons are saving far more lives of warfighters and also resulting in more-targeted attacks that result in fewer civilian casualties.
It could go either way. The idea that there is a human making that decision when your adversary is using autonomous systems is not necessarily a beneficial impact. I wish I could give a clearer answer of, “Yes, that would be bad or this would be good,” but it is too complicated for that.
ASHA RANGAPPA: JC, in the world of finance, you mentioned the 2008 crisis. Before that we can point to any number of financial scandals, for example, Enron. The tension there in accountability seems I think to the layperson that we are going for shareholder value to maximize profits, and it is up to the regulators to stop us. I want to get to regulation too, but where does the accountability lie there? Is this an arena where people can self-police?
JC DE SWAAN: I would say first that you cannot outsource ethics to regulation in finance. That is very hard. One of the challenges is that in finance an enormous amount of financial activity ends up being legal, within the rules but arguably unethical because maybe they are extracting value from their customers, or maybe more complicated, they are actually serving their customers faithfully and well, but they are extracting value from other people. It is hard for regulators to address that.
I will give you an example. Years ago, the governments of Italy and Greece were breaching the European Union rules for indebtedness. They were blowing past the limits of indebtedness. They went to a couple of investment banks, Goldman Sachs and JPMorgan, to try to address this issue, and these banks, enormously savvy and sophisticated, were able to solve the problem of Italy and Greece in a very narrow way. They found a regulatory reporting loophole, and they used that and applied a derivatives strategy that essentially allowed Italy and Greece to report numbers that were within the European Union guidelines.
That is interesting because you would say, “Well, they served their customers super-well, but in a very narrow way.” They would have been, I am sure, paid a lot for this and in some ways for good reason because that sophistication and savviness is very rare, and they solved the problem.
But when you step back from this, it is hard not to look at this and say, “Wow, in some ways they extracted value from the rest of society.”
That particular situation is an example of where it is impossible to regulate, so when you think about accountability it has to be a combination of regulation but also from within these firms, making and applying norms.
You can do that in different ways. It is hard, but one of the ways in which you can do it is that within a firm you can position yourself as more ethical and more cognizant of norms. What is interesting is that that speaks to younger people, so that could be a recruiting strategy because in finance it is all about the ability to attract the best talent. There is an area for this.
At a higher level, from a top-down perspective when you think about accountability, collective action amongst different firms can solve some of these issues. One of the challenges that we are grappling with right now in finance is an ethical issue in the recruiting of young graduates from colleges who want to work in private equity. These young graduates, in order to work in private equity, have to do two years of investment banking, and what we are seeing is that there is a game theory problem in that the private equity firms have started recruiting these young graduates earlier and earlier, up to the point where they are being recruited as they graduate from college but before they start their investment banking jobs.
That puts them in impossible ethical situations because they have already accepted a job at a different firm that is going to start two years later, and now they are going to work in investment banking without telling their employer that they have already accepted another job, so they might be put on deals that they should not be put on or might have information they should not have, all sorts of ethical issues. The problem is that these private equity firms are so focused on the talent competition that they keep recruiting earlier and earlier. This is an example of an erosion of a norm that has happened over the years.
The only way to really deal with it is to have some sort of collective bargaining, like an institution, maybe a not-for-profit that steps in and brings all these private equity firms together and says, “Look, we are going to stop recruiting earlier than this date.” So there are solutions, but they are hard. In some ways it is a mosaic of pressure points.
ASHA RANGAPPA: I think it is interesting that you suggested that firms can position themselves as, “We care a lot about ethics and that will resonate with young people.” Do you think ethics matters to younger generations? It feels like from the side of these companies and things that you are working with in your fields that ethics is for losers.
KAT DUFFY: I totally disagree. The Gen Zers are giving me such hope. It is a different type of protest movement, a different type of social organizing in a way that me and all my forties-ness is way too old to understand. I am seeing this constantly among college students, people in their early to mid-20s. There is a real divide around whether or not to use AI tools at all, real concerns about them.
I have children who are of high school and below age. These are children who are already looking at these tools and saying, “I don’t know that that is going to make me smarter. I don’t know that that is good for me.” They are coming at this with totally different questions.
What is it like to be that age, especially in the United States of America, and be coming up at a moment when everyone who was in charge let the planet burn, is letting democracy collapse, is saddling you with trillions of dollars of debt that you will never understand how to pay for, and where you are looking at a lifetime of lesser returns across the board than the generations before you? Why on earth should that generation buy into our existing ethical constructs? I don’t think the problem is them.
ASHA RANGAPPA: I don’t think the problem is them either. Are we really rewarding ethical behavior? These firms that are recruiting them, I don’t know which ones claim that they are super-ethical. Anthropic seems like the one that explicitly has it as its mission and might have done something. The fossil fuel industry does not seem to care a lot.
Do you know what I mean? In a scarcity mentality where getting the job and making the money is how you get ahead—not for nothing, but at Princeton they just walked back the honor code because basically everybody is cheating.
JC DE SWAAN: Not everybody, but it has been a huge issue. We have had an honor code for 133 years, and it has been a struggle over the last few years. There has been a lot of grade inflation. Anecdotally, at least in my classes I can see an inflection point over the last three years. In the Economics Department it is mandated that all of the exams, midterms and finals, are to be in the classroom with blue books and paper.
To Kat’s point, I think it is interesting about the younger generation. I have two girls in middle school, and they have such a visceral reaction to climate issues and AI. It is at the point where any time they come by me and see me using AI they scream at me. That reaction is interesting.
I have seen a wave actually amongst my students. Post-global financial crisis there were a number of years where a lot of the students were increasingly interested in finding financial jobs where they could be good citizens. That was an important part of the conversation.
ASHA RANGAPPA: Like impact investing.
JC DE SWAAN: Yes. That is when we saw a surge of interest in impact investing, which was challenging because there were so few impact investing firms relative to the interest there was in impact investing.
I have to say that propensity to be very focused on, “How can I be a good citizen and work in finance?” has been more muted in the last three or four years, and I do not know to what extent it is an impact from COVID-19 or from something else.
ASHA RANGAPPA: I have one more question for Samira to maybe bring some of this together. The Center for Earth Ethics draws on faith and Indigenous traditions. We talked about some of the practices. Is there a way to create a shared moral language that we can all agree on, or is that a whole Pandora’s box?
SAMIRA SIDDIQUE: That is a great question and feeds off of the discussion we just had about what ethics looks like for the younger generation these days. To piggyback off that and to answer your question, I think going beyond ethical frameworks, the word “ethics” can be alienating for folks. It is a lofty thing.
Going deeper, to the base level of what are our shared values here, what I have seen a lot in young people and not just people who call themselves “climate activists” but your average teen—I have a lot of them in my family—is that people are looking for the deeper meanings behind things because of these very clear ruptures in our institutions that are obvious at this point, especially after COVID-19. No one really knows what is going on. With the rise of AI and these technologies in our day-to-day we all know too much about what is going on everywhere, it is overwhelming and there is a crisis of deep alienation that I think many of us feel, especially young people.
The pushback we are seeing that Kat and JC alluded to is that with the rise of AI there are a lot of young people who are now gravitating toward in-person connection in beautiful ways that I think are not talked about enough, like the undergrounds and mycelium networks of people making these third spaces and different ways of being that are not captured in popular media or the ways that institutions run because we are all conditioned to do things in a business-as-usual fashion, which is working harder and faster and not taking breaks for ourselves and having these basic connections.
Going back to your question, yes, “Earth ethics” for the Center basically is using the best ancient knowledge and wisdom from different faith and spiritual traditions that have been around for thousands and thousands of years as well as indigenous practice, ritual, and ceremony to understand how to better live in a right relationship with ourselves and other living beings to forefront a more just society and way of being.
That is a very big idea, but it ultimately comes back to the basic values of reciprocity and what we owe to each other and other living beings on the Earth and seeing all of what is around us as interconnected. So, what is happening within me is connected to you and what I am seeing in you is also within myself. That goes for the rivers and trees as well. These are all living beings that affect each other in very deep ways.
Even if we are not talking about it like that, these are the essential values that we try to understand, publicize, and connect and convene people around, and I think that sense of connection is what people are looking for and moving toward, even in these subconscious ways because connection and relationship is what we are built for. Creating those spaces where people can feel that is a possibility is the ultimate pushback in this day and age, being with one another in a good way and being present. It sounds like basic stuff, but it is very powerful.
KAT DUFFY: Let me throw in a concrete example that I think is hopefully multigenerational as well in terms of societal agreement, where we are aligned in terms of reciprocity or caring for each other.
Meta glasses or augmented-reality glasses in general; is everybody clear on these in the room? Straw poll? If you are a privacy advocate, no, thank you. They are a horrifying invention if your priority is privacy protection.
If, however, your priority is disability rights and you are trying to make sure that the visually impaired, for example, have the most access possible, they are a miracle. They are an absolutely miraculous invention.
So the issue is not Meta glasses, and we have already come together as a society to say we want to promote accessibility for people with visual impairment, and ideally—this is something where we do have some generational shifts—we want to be able to protect each other’s privacy. So the issue is not that Meta glasses are okay or not okay.
What I would prefer to see is a law that states, “If you are going to have a consumer-facing device sitting on someone’s face that can record everything in front of it, that thing has got to be lit up bright green. Whenever you are recording, it cannot be like a little dot on the side. You are going to walk around with bright green glowing glasses.”
That takes us back, JC, to your point on norms versus regulation. It is the norms then of the people who are around the individual with bright green glowing glasses who are going to say, “Uh-uh, get out or take them off or turn it off,” but it is the norms that allow a community to come together around that and say that is not okay.
On the other hand, let’s say that there is a visually impaired person in the same way that we have canes. Canes have different types of markings on them to indicate the level of visual impairment that someone with that cane has. If it is a bright rainbow, that is a specific designated use of that particular technology for someone who has visual impairment, and that is protected under the Americans with Disabilities Act, and everybody knows what is going on there, and maybe it is replacing a cane.
This is where I feel there are a lot of spaces for us to get more targeted, to say that we are okay with this use case and not okay with this use case. It is not about preventing the technology from rolling forward.
I will tell you that if Meta glasses are being designed to protect accessibility rights, that is not a revenue-generating model at all and that technology will stall until something that is revenue-generating that is a societally acceptable model rolls around. I think the challenge right now is that we are allowing everything to be societally acceptable when we do not actually feel that it is; we just have not worked out societal accountability for it yet.
ASHA RANGAPPA: I love your example because what it gets to is a certain amount of transparency also and accountability. The idea of trust and reciprocity, Samira, that you were talking about and the responsibility to the greater good was making me thing of de Tocqueville’s idea of “self-interest well-understood” and how we have lost that as well, a sense of being able to pursue things that maximize our own interests but also that lift the general welfare in these different areas.
We should turn to questions.
QUESTION: Very fascinating discussion. It reminded me of an issue I had in a graduate class at Princeton University in economics, where I had an argument with a professor.
Basically the topic was on the innovation economy. The professor’s point of view was that as long as something contributes to gross domestic product (GDP) and is quantifiable it has value. It echoed this conversation, so here is the next question: If that is not the case, what are the “objective” indicators that we should be looking at to avoid the subjectiveness of “I think this and they think this,” because someone mentioned there was a decline in corporate responsibility? I think other people could argue there has been an increase because having more public disclosure and forcing companies to be more transparent about what they are doing and their supply chain is changing their behavior, and they are actually doing things in a more positive way.
What would the panel say are the sort of things where we could say, “This is a black-and-white indicator showing movement of direction toward more responsible ethical behavior,” whether it is for companies or other actors in society?
KAT DUFFY: Independent evaluation and oversight in the same way you see with carbon credits, although it is questionable to me in climate. I understand where the idea came from. Are we really seeing positive returns from it in terms of the climate because you are just letting people write off their carbon use?
You see this in the same way with “compliance theater” essentially inside of finance. We are seeing the same thing in benchmarking, for example, with AI models. You put out a benchmark to say that this model is good at this or not good at this, whatever it might be, but then inside the labs what is happening is when a model is coming out and it is not hitting a certain benchmark, they just throw a ton of engineers at hitting that exact benchmark to get above it so they can get the model out.
It is still just the lab itself in many respects saying, “This is what we found, this is what we produced,” et cetera. There is no world in which self-regulation of any industry is going to be effective. You cannot expect the tech industry to regulate itself and have it actually play out in the public interest. You cannot expect the financial industry to regulate itself and have that wholly play out in the public interest. It just does not work that way.
To me one clear bright line we need to get to is, what does independent investigatory and analytical capability look like that supports public-interest goals and the reporting around that? We are not there yet, but we could get there far more quickly than we have so far.
ASHA RANGAPPA: I would add that a big, glaring, neon alarm is when the independent oversight mechanisms that exist are dismantled. You are probably moving in a bad direction.
KAT DUFFY: Look at the data center in Memphis. There has been a lot of protesting of this because this data center was producing terrible outcomes for the community around it, and there is great reporting that came out of the Kapor Foundation around the data centers that had been built up in California and the disproportionate degree to which those data centers were being placed in already economically vulnerable communities.
In Memphis what happened is that they cut short the permitting. In order to get this data center spun up, they waived a lot of the permitting requirements to get it going. Again, the question becomes, is the problem the data center or is the problem that we have the framework, we have the things we want to protect against, and we have the permitting for those community protections, and they were skipped? Somebody allowed them to be skipped.
Where does the accountability sit there? I would argue that the accountability sits with whoever let the permitting slide, first and foremost, and then there are questions around whether that permitting is adequate for what needs to be governed. That is a different question, but that to me is a clear example of public interest harms. There are public interest authorities in place that were ridden over because of the perceived financial returns of getting this data center going.
ASHA RANGAPPA: We have some questions from the virtual audience. Here is one: “Could you share some concrete tools or frameworks that organizations can practically use to re-center ethics in their day-to-day activities and decision making?”
JC DE SWAAN: This is a discussion I have with my students a lot, what is the right framework to use, whether it is for us or internally at a firm? We consider the traditional frameworks that you will be familiar with. We will approach a problem using deontology, consequentialism, and virtue ethics.
I also spend part of my time in an investment fund, and we encounter moral issues all the time. The reason we encounter moral issues all the time is because when you work in finance you are constantly faced with conflicts of interest, and for a lot of these situations there are no easy answers.
Frankly, the framework I have found most useful is, and you are not going to be impressed here, literally sitting and writing down in memo form to how your decision will be seen if it was a headline in whatever media you care about, to what extent would you be comfortable if everybody else in the industry made the same decision, and then to what extent would you be comfortable if you were somehow remembered partly by that decision?
This is completely simplistic, but personally I have found that within a firm if you do not just think about it but actually write it in memo form, that transparency crystalizes a lot of issues that are often swept under the rug.
I will say that one of the key issues that affects the finance industry is the fact that there are a lot of very good people who are thoughtful and went to great schools who end up making decisions which from the outside you would look and think, Wow, that doesn’t look right. That feels unethical. But they do not see it at all, and a lot of the reason is because we often have these cognitive biases, these blind spots.
One of them is that when you are deeply embedded in an organization you are hyperfocused, laser-like focused on one or two metrics that your managers are focused on, but you are so deeply enmeshed in a complex web of incentives and pressure points that you end up being completely oblivious to the moral dimension of any of your decisions. As a result, that clarity of writing down things very clearly in memo form makes a difference in my mind.
ASHA RANGAPPA: There is psychological research about taking a third-person perspective on yourself leading to more clarity, especially when it comes to ethical decisions. When I was in the Federal Bureau of Investigation, we called this the “Dateline rule,” which was when you are doing something and writing it up, imagine that it is on Dateline with the big yellow headline, and would you be okay with that?
I am going to go to another question: “Who should have the legitimate authority to define, force, and revise the ethical boundaries of systems whose consequences are global?”
SAMIRA SIDDIQUE: I think about this a lot. Climate change is a global problem with very localized effects, so every community is going to be impacted by it if it is not already. A lot of my work is at the United Nations and other global convenings, but the Center for Earth Ethics is also very place-based, so I think about the scale of things a lot.
Going back to previous questions about the right ethical frameworks to look at, I always take my cue from the climate and environmental justice realm. Within those ideas and frameworks we talk a lot about participatory justice, a basic, simple idea about making sure the right people are at the table and that frontline communities—indigenous communities and people of color, long-time activists that are deeply rooted in place—are the ones leading the way here and are part of the institutional decisions being made.
This is not perfectly quantifiable. It is not a GDP measure, but it is always an aspiration in every space that we are in.
KAT DUFFY: That idea that someone “should” and “could” has never existed in the history of humanity, and I would argue it never will. There is no “should” there because I do not think as a species we are advanced enough to make that happen.
What we are seeing, at least in AI and in tech in general, is a push toward digital sovereignty and sovereign AI. This is a very common concept right now, and at its core what it is about is agency and greater local agency over where your data is, who owns it, who controls it, and who has access to it. Again, there are a lot of reasons you could say I am absolutely for that and I want to be able to control my data.
For example, how long have we been exploiting Indigenous cultures? If we were able to take the vast amount of knowledge that has been acquired by an indigenous community in terms of their local ecosystem and how it works, local remedies, and all of those things, you want that to remain with a community and be a product of the community for the community and not just be taken and exploited. By the same token, you are talking about a technology that can speed and scale political and economic centralization of control.
One of the big challenges is that when you talk about something like sovereign AI and data localization the next step is that that is held by the government. That is held by the nation-state. That is the unit of measurement in that equation. That is where sovereignty sits.
The critical assumption underpinning that if you are going to be in favor of it, I would presume, is that that government reflects the consent of the governed, that that government is a government where citizens can decide they want a different government or they want a government making different decisions. When that is not the government at play, then what you are talking about instead is a technology that can dramatically increase and harden what we already have, which is rising levels of authoritarianism and dramatically diminish democratic values and democratic governments around the globe.
This question around who should be accountable or who should be in charge, I do think in AI at least it is important to understand that there is a real push toward more local agency, ownership, and control. I also think it is commensurate upon the international community to continue to insist that just because you may be exerting sovereignty there, we have all litigated and agreed at this point that you cannot exert your sovereignty as an excuse for violating human rights, so human rights protections have to be part and parcel of whatever type of sovereign AI or sovereign technology you are building. Not in ours, but in most countries that would include social, economic, and cultural rights.
QUESTION: I appreciated your framework, Kat, in terms of competing value systems. When I think about the utility of applied ethics, it is, one, to recognize that there are competing value systems, and, two, to understand how you can come together under a bigger, maybe pluralistic umbrella or a universality umbrella and think about these competing value systems knowing that you have to work with other people.
I would love to hear JC and Samira take Kat’s framework and say where you think there are good-faith conversations to be had around competing values claims in your respective areas. An example or two would be great to hear.
JC DE SWAAN: In finance but more generally in the business sector I think the big discussion over the years has been, what is the purpose and mission of a firm? In the United States by and large, going back to a Milton Friedman piece that came out in the 1970s, we have had this construct of the primary purpose of a firm being to maximize shareholder value. That is not the case in other parts of the world. If you look at places like Canada, Germany, France, and Japan, they have very different constructs, and what you see is that over time there is a push for more balance when there is too extreme a version of that framework.
In the United States, after the global financial crisis we saw a move toward what people refer to as “stakeholder capitalism,” where there was more attention given not just to the shareholders but to other stakeholders: employees, suppliers, and the debt holders.
I have been spending a lot of my time working in Japan, and they have a dramatically different approach to this. They might not admit it, but when you look at their actions you would infer that the primary purpose of a firm there is to work for the benefit of its employees, which is dramatically different from the United States.
For each of these competing systems there are trade-offs. In Japan it is part of a value system that is very focused, so CEOs are extremely focused on the long-term and not the short-term value of their company and their reputation. What they ultimately want is to be seen as great stewards of their company 300 years from now. They want to be looked back on as CEO number 37, who really took care, and ultimately their metric is the stability of the employee base.
The trade-off is that that makes them less focused on performance and entirely focused on stability and less on productivity. Starting in 2013 they pushed toward more balance. Often what you find is that these value systems have to work in the framework of a culture, and more balance is typically better.
SAMIRA SIDDIQUE: That is a great question. I think the key phrase is “good-faith actors.” I would say that we cannot include climate deniers in this conversation because that is a hard line. You just cannot agree at that point on facts.
The Center for Earth Ethics is one of the conveners of a major global initiative called the Global Ethical Stocktake, which started in the lead-up to last year’s UN Climate Conference in partnership with the Brazil Ministry of Environment, and we are taking it forward for the next two years. Basically this is a series of high-level dialogues happening on each continent as well as hundreds of more grassroots-level dialogues, bringing in ethicists but also artists, indigenous elders, youth, activists, and scientists to forefront what are the ethics, values, and wisdom traditions that we need to deal with the climate crisis. These are people coming together from all different perspectives but all in good faith, believing in the problem, and asking what are the issues not captured in our scientific and technical reports at the UN Climate Conferences and bringing the frontline community perspectives and real human impacts that still are not reflected in these climate conferences that now have been going on for 31 years.
There is still a lot more conversation and dialogue that we need to have. This is a major initiative that we are working on. It is exciting and shows that there is a shift happening now in the climate community around bringing in these values and ethics in a meaningful way. Good-faith actors are often hard to find when we are having these climate conversations.
ASHA RANGAPPA: We are at time. Thank you, everyone, for your participation.
Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Affairs is an independent and nonpartisan nonprofit. The views expressed within this panel are those of the speakers and do not necessarily reflect the position of Carnegie Council.

