Donald Trump & Xi Jinping in Beijing, November 2017. CREDIT: <a href="">Official White House Photo by Andrea Hanks</a>.
Donald Trump & Xi Jinping in Beijing, November 2017. CREDIT: Official White House Photo by Andrea Hanks.

Searching for a Post-Pandemic Order

Sep 25, 2020

This article first appeared on the Ethics & International Affairs blog.

The Carnegie Council's U.S. Global Engagement program held a fascinating and provocative discussion with Ali Wyne of the Atlantic Council, looking at the question of the relevance of the narrative of great power competition among U.S. voters. Something that Ali said in that conversation has continued to resonate with me. In discussing great power competition, he noted that at present, it is conceived in reactive terms: the United States "responding" to steps taken by states like China or Russia. But the United States needs to be able to move beyond response to, as Ali put it, developing an "affirmative agenda" for the "post-pandemic order," where the U.S. can again galvanize collective action among the nations of the world.

Per Carnegie Council polling, a majority of respondents from the "informed, engaged general public" worry about the world become more dangerous and are concerned about the implications of world affairs being defined by competition or confrontation as opposed to cooperation. At the same time, there seems to be growing support for reorienting trade relations to strengthen ties among the democracies and lessen dependence on China and other authoritarian states.

Thinking about a post-pandemic order may seem premature while we move through a second wave of COVID-19, but the coronavirus, as well as other environmental considerations, are reshaping the parameters of the international system. But having a forward-looking "affirmative agenda" is exactly what is needed.

I was reminded of that in listening to the comments of senior German and U.S. officials in the first day of the fall 2020 Loisach Group, a joint German-American forum for defense and security policy. The subject of this fall's conclave is the Euro-American community's response to a rising China, and what was striking is how a purely "great power competition" narrative seemed insufficient as a basis for joint action. Instead, there is an active search for framing what Wyne describes as an "affirmative agenda"—and with the recognition that an affirmative agenda for the 2020s does not equate to turning the clock back to a pre-2016 approach.

You may also like

CREDIT: 2020 <a href=>survey of attitudes</a>, U.S. Global Engagement program. Map provided by <a href=>Pixabay (CC)</a>.

MAR 9, 2020 Article

What Do Americans Think . . .

The U.S. Global Engagement program at Carnegie Council has been conducting a survey of attitudes about U.S. foreign policy with an eye to ...

H&M Asia flagship store, Causeway Bay, Hong Kong. CREDIT: <a href=>Wpcpey/Wikimedia</a> <a href=>(CC)</a>

SEP 21, 2020 Article

Will Consumers Pay More To Not Source from China?

Retailer H&M will stop relying on Chinese garment factories and suppliers located in Xinjiang, over concerns about the use of Uyghers as forced labor. ...

The Loisach Group at the Munich Security Conference 2018. CREDIT: <a href=>George C. Marshall European Center for Security Studies (CC)</a>

DEC 11, 2019 Article

Loisach Group and the Democratic Community Narrative

Senior Fellow Nikolas Gvosdev reports from the Berlin meetings of the Losiach Group, a U.S.-German strategic dialogue, where the trans-Atlantic relationship and the ...

Satellite view of California, September 9, 2020. Source: <a href=>U.S. National Weather Service/Wikimedia (Public Domain)</a>.

SEP 11, 2020 Article

Ecological Dimension of Foreign Policy

One of the emerging narratives about United States foreign policy is the use of climate change as a central organizing principle. How can ecological and ...

COVID-19 samples being studied at the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research, Silver Spring, Maryland, June 2020.<br> CREDIT: <a href="">U.S. Army photo by Mike Walters</a>

SEP 3, 2020 Article

The Ethics of Non-Cooperation: COVID Vaccine Questions

The search for a COVID-19 vaccine is another example of how the pandemic has increased competition among nations, writes Senior Fellow Nikolas Gvosdev. Will the ...