Donald Trump meets with Xi Jinping in June 2019 at the G20 Summit in Osaka, Japan. CREDIT: <a href=https://www.flickr.com/photos/whitehouse/48162295476/>Official White House Photo/Shealah Craighead (CC)</a>.
Donald Trump meets with Xi Jinping in June 2019 at the G20 Summit in Osaka, Japan. CREDIT: Official White House Photo/Shealah Craighead (CC).

Hybrid Narratives and Competing with China

Jan 30, 2020

This article first appeared on the Ethics & International Affairs blog.

The Center for a New American Security (CNAS) has released its Congressionally requested report on what the American approach ought to be in order to cope and compete with a rising China. In reading "Rising to the China Challenge: Renewing American Competitiveness in the Indo-Pacific," what struck me was how the report's recommendations are grounded in a number of the new and emerging narratives about the role and scope of U.S. engagement in the world—a clear effort to broaden the potential base of support for its recommendations beyond the traditional "bipartisan consensus" about the need for the United States to exercise "leadership" in the world.

The "seven vectors" on which a new U.S. approach should be based reflect this:

  1. Sustaining conventional military deterrence
  2. Securing vital U.S. technological advantages
  3. Bolstering U.S. economic power and leadership
  4. Strengthening American diplomacy
  5. Competing over ideology and narrative
  6. Promoting digital freedom and countering high-tech illiberalism
  7. Cultivating the talent to compete with China

Mind you, the report largely follows the established Washington think tank script for its recommendations, and overall its tone would fall under our category of the "restorationist" approach. Yet it is also important to see how it creates hooks in its advice meant to appeal to other constituencies. There is a call for closer partnerships to deal with climate change and developing resiliency; an appeal to defend and enhance human rights; a definitive call for forging a closer democratic community among the United States and its principal partners. But what was most apparent to me was to see the recognition that the "America First" impulse in American political discourse must be addressed. The explicit calls for linking American approaches in the Indo-Pacific region to domestic economic constituencies; the apparent embrace of aspects of the “regeneration” narrative, even the recognition that the benefits of American activism in the region are just not automatically assumed to be beneficial but must be directly connected to American domestic concerns–testify to how the shifts in American political discourse about what the U.S. should be doing in the world are having an impact.

Of course, the CNAS report remains grounded largely in assumptions about the desirability of American forward engagement. It is not a blueprint that would have been developed by the Cato Institute or the Institute for Policy Studies. Yet its authors recognize that long-term policy towards China must be grounded in a strategy that rests on broad foundations in the American body politic–and this means coming to terms with the objections raised by those who prefer to see some degree of retrenchment or those who want to see more emphasis on values or climate.

You may also like

President Donald J. Trump and President Xi Jinping hold a bilateral meeting in Beijing on November 9, 2017. CREDIT: <a href=https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/more-photos-foreign-trip/>The White House (CC)</a>.

AUG 20, 2019 Article

Ethical Considerations in a Trade War with China

Are there ethical considerations that need to be factored in as part of assessing the merits of a "trade war" with the People's Republic of ...

(L to R) Former Uzbeki President Islam Karimov, Russian President Vladimir Putin, Chinese President Xi Jinping in Tashkent, Uzbekistan, June 2016. CREDIT: <a href=http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/52257>kremlin.ru (CC)</a>

AUG 23, 2019 Article

The Ethics of Trade with China and Authoritarian Upgrading

Increased foreign investment and engagement is producing, not democratization, but "authoritarian upgrading," where selected reforms are designed to legitimize a softer authoritarianism. This presents an ...

President Donald Trump at the 74th session of the United Nations General Assembly in New York, September 2019. CREDIT: <a href=https://www.flickr.com/photos/whitehouse/48791288231/>The White House (CC)</a>.

OCT 25, 2019 Article

The Search for a New Narrative: Recasting American Involvement in the International System

This project on U.S. Global Engagement was launched in 2018. An initial report, released in December 2018, diagnosed the causes and symptoms of the narrative collapse ...

Senator Bernie Sanders at the 2019 California Democratic Party State Convention in San Francisco. CREDIT: <a href="https://flickr.com/photos/gageskidmore/48023053593/">Gage Skidmore</a> <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/">(CC)</a>

JAN 24, 2020 Article

The Democratic Debate and Competing Narratives

As the Democratic field of presidential candidates narrows, the contenders are beginning to devote more attention to foreign policy and Senior Fellow Nikolas Gvosdev has ...

American and Floridian flags wave in Viera, FL. CREDIT: <a href=https://www.flickr.com/photos/rusty_clark/32170527104/>Rusty Clark (CC)</a>.

JAN 23, 2020 Article

Foreign Policy Narratives in Palm Beach

After an invitation to speak at a gathering of the Palm Beach chapter of the United Nations Association of the United States, U.S. Global ...

President Trump delivers remarks on Jan. 8, 2020 at the White House. <a href=https://www.flickr.com/photos/whitehouse/49351700228/>Official White House Photo by Joyce N. Boghosian/Public Domain</a>.

JAN 13, 2020 Article

A Parting of Values: America First versus Transactionalism

"The existing divide in American foreign policy discourse has been the extent to which the U.S. must actively propagate and spread its values, or ...