Global Ethics Corner: Should Adultery be Illegal for Military Personnel?

Nov 19, 2012

Although he was allegedly retired from the military when the affair took place, the scandal surrounding David Petraeus highlights the different ethical standard that members of the armed services are held to. Should adultery be deemed illegal for military personnel?

The resignation of CIA Director David Petraeus was as sudden as it was alarming. News that the retired U.S. General had engaged in an extramarital affair has left the intelligence community scrambling for a competent replacement. But it’s also sparked some soul-searching within military circles, as many ponder the ethical implications of Petraeus’s downfall.

Although some would argue that Petraeus’s affair made him vulnerable to blackmail, at present there’s no indication that his conduct broke any laws. But if Petraeus were still in the military, it would be a different story. That’s because adultery is illegal under military lawpunishable by reprimand, dismissal, and even prison.

The illegality of adultery offers just one example of how military personnel are held to a higher ethical standard than civilians. But is it a fair standard to set? Should adultery be illegal for military personnel?

Many members of the military say it should be. They believe adultery represents a threat to military discipline. It can endanger troop morale and compromise the public’s faith in the military.

Others believe that such notions are outdated. After all, since military professionals now do multiple tours of duty away from their spouses, cases of adultery are only likely to rise. What’s more, when it comes to personal relations, military professionals are just as prone to mistakes as their civilian counterparts. A "military apart" is a noble phrase, but when it comes to adultery, is it fair to expect a higher standard? Is it realistic?

As the U.S. reflects on the ethical standards of its military, what do you think? Should military professionals be held to a stricter moral code than civilians? And should a prohibition against adultery be part of that code?

By Marlene Spoerri

For more information see

Mark Thompson, "An Army Apart: The Widening Military-Civilian Gap," Time, November 10, 2011

Ian Fisher, "Army's Adultery Rule Is Don't Get Caught," The New York Times, May 17, 1998

Mark Memmott, "Petraeus Affair Widens: Who's Who & What's What? Here's A Guide," NPR, November 13, 2012

Thom Shanker, "Concern Grows Over Top Military Officers’ Ethics," The New York Times, November 12, 2012

Photo credits in order of appearance:
Hector Alejandro
CIA
DVIDSHUB
Bill Rhodes
Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
Thomas Hawk
Jennuine Captures
Benjamin Faske / U.S. Army
Victoria Pickering
Sharla Lewis / U.S. Army
Clifford Horn
Elizabeth Alexander/U.S. Army
isafmedia

You may also like

APR 26, 2022 Podcast

The Promise & Peril of Brain Machine Interfaces, with Ricardo Chavarriaga

In this "Artificial Intelligence & Equality" podcast, Senior Fellow Anja Kaspersen talks with Dr. Ricardo Chavarriaga about the promise and peril of brain-machine interfaces and cognitive ...

AUG 27, 2021 Journal

Ethics & International Affairs Volume 35.2 (Summer 2021)

The highlight of this issue is a roundtable organized by Adrian Gallagher on the responsibility to protect in a changing world order. The roundtable contains ...

DEC 21, 2020 Podcast

AI & Equality Initiative: Algorithmic Bias & the Ethical Implications

In this AI & Equality Initiative podcast, Senior Fellow Anja Kaspersen speaks with three researchers working with the University of Melbourne's Centre for AI and Digital ...