Global Ethics Corner: Whose Art Is It?

Oct 2, 2009

Should cultural treasures, acquired under dubious circumstances, be returned to their places of origin?

Should cultural treasures, acquired under dubious circumstances, be returned to their places of origin?

Lord Elgin ripped the Elgin Marbles from the Greek Parthenon in 1802-12 and transferred them to the British Museum. Even if he had permission, as he claimed, he vandalized the Parthenon and took advantage of British power vis-à-vis the dying Ottoman Empire.

Many contend that keeping the Marbles in London saved them from certain damage and deterioration. But in June 2009, a state-of-the-art museum opened in Greece, with an empty space reserved for the Marbles.

The national position argues that countries are entitled to their past, their heritage, especially when improperly acquired; that there is a legal and a moral claim. As long as treasures can be safely housed, they should go back to their origin, where they can be seen in the context of their native soil.

The cosmopolitan position is that cultural treasures are a common, global inheritance. Museums with diverse collections are world heritage centers. Seeing different cultures all in one place causes visitors to make connections, creating a shared experience and worldview.

Heritage of nations or mankind? What do you think?

By Madeleine Lynn

With thanks to The New York Review of Books. For more on this topic, see Who Should Own the World's Antiquities? and Grading the New Acropolis.

You may also like

MAY 20, 2025 Podcast

Character not Compliance, with Edward Brooks

Oxford's Dr. Edward Brooks joins "Values & Interests" to discuss how embracing ethics can unlock better thinking, relationships, and outcomes in our personal and professional lives.

Left to right: Zhanna Malekos Smith, Mai'a Cross, Diane Howard, Ann C Thresher. CREDIT: Noha Mahmoud.

APR 4, 2025 Video

Unlocking Cooperation: Space Diplomacy

In this event, Northeastern University’s Ethics Institute partnered with Carnegie Council to host a convening on the future of international space governance, security, & sustainability.

MAR 18, 2025 Podcast

Small States, Mutual Respect, and the Future of the International System, with Ambassador Ali Naseer Mohamed

Ambassador Ali Naseer Mohamed, permanent representative of the Maldives to the UN, discusses the vital role of small states at this critical global moment.

Not translated

This content has not yet been translated into your language. You can request a translation by clicking the button below.

Request Translation