Global Ethics Corner: The Great Firewall of China

Feb 20, 2009

Should foreign companies fudge a commitment to free speech to gain early market access? Is some information better than none, or is censorship a black and white issue?

Rebecca MacKinnon notes that, in China, the Great Firewall involves search engine censorship.

You get different results when you search for "Tiananmen massacre" on Western or on Chinese Similarly, banned sites pop up as temporary technical errors, and authors of sensitive blog posts are told that "community editors" will get back to them.

The Chinese government worries about online activism moving into the streets, about disorder. They proactively shape opinions online, paying loyalists 50 cents per post for favorable opinions.

Communications companies mediate between people and governments, and censorship presents companies with ethical choices.

Should foreign companies fudge a commitment to free speech to gain early market access? Is shareholder value the company’s single priority? How sensitive are companies to domestic affairs of sovereign states? Is some openness better than none?

Chinese private enterprises are legally responsible for the content their users post, and don't have the luxury of debating these questions.

What do you think? Should there be no censorship, or should countries manage Internet access for the publics’ good? Doesn’t the West monitor for pornography and terrorism? Is censorship a black and white issue, or a continuum?

Adapted from Evan O'Neil's notes on a presentation by Policy Innovations advisor Rebecca MacKinnon

To post a comment, go to the Global Ethics Corner slideshow.

You may also like

APR 14, 2020 Podcast

Facial Recognition, the Future of Privacy, & COVID-19, with Brenda Leong

In this wide-ranging talk, Future of Privacy Forum's Brenda Leong discusses the commercial uses of facial recognition technology, concerns about privacy and bias, how it's ...

CV Dazzle demonstrates facial recognition software at The Web We Want Festival. CREDIT: <a href=>Pete Woodhead (CC)</a>.

APR 7, 2020 Podcast

Facial Recognition Technology, Policy, & the Pandemic, with Jameson Spivack

Jameson Spivack, policy associate at Georgetown Law's Center on Privacy and Technology, discusses some of the most pressing policy issues when it comes to facial ...

FEB 9, 2022 Podcast

Where is the Public Square for the Digital Information Age? with Stelios Vassilakis

In this episode of the "Artificial Intelligence & Equality Initiative" podcast, Senior Fellow Anja Kaspersen and Carnegie Council President Joel Rosenthal sit down with the Stavros ...