There is much that is interesting in Anthony Burke's essay. Unfortunately, Burke is unable to resist hyperbolic language and too readily substitutes rhetorical onslaught for compelling argument. For example, those he criticizes as being neo-imperialists in liberal internationalist clothing are many times over said to present "disturbing" or "disturbing indeed" arguments. We are told that liberty is a "hermaphrodite"; that the war on terrorism constitutes "the democracy that slaughters, the liberator that tortures" (p. 73), as if Abu Ghraib is standard policy rather than aberration and the deaths of civilians intentional rather than a tragic unintended consequence of fighting. Burke's opponents, he says, deploy "notoriously vague" and "fear-soaked rhetoric" as they "scandalously" mimic the ICISS report's title (p. 76). Citing Jürgen Habermas, he calls the war against Saddam Hussein an "unimaginable break" with existing norms (pp. 75, 76). This suggests that there are "imaginable breaks," but we do not know anything about the criteria he is applying. Reserving sunny language for his own proposed alternatives, Burke blasts the idea of state sovereignty itself as "violent and exclusivist," and "linger[ing], like a latent illness, in the very depths of modern cosmopolitanism" (p. 74). These excesses are distracting and cloud the observations in his essay that are perceptive and deserve serious consideration.
You may also like
NOV 6, 2026 • Podcast
Moral Courage, Individual Agency, and Institutional Trust
Former FBI special agent Asha Rangappa joins “Values & Interests” to discuss the ethical challenges facing public servants in an era of eroding institutional norms.
Hosted by Kevin Maloney
NOV 3, 2026 • Video
Carnegie Ethics Fellows Symposium 2026
Access expert panels on water ethics, AI in healthcare, economic and national security, and AI in humanitarian response, moderated by the Carnegie Ethics Fellows.
Hosted by Harsh Suri, Nadav Avihay, Kathy Kim, Rebecca Distler, Denver Barrows, Joshua Acosta, Nicholas Bayer, Molly Schaeffer, Kathleen Egan, & Brian A. Mateo
OCT 29, 2026 • Video
Re-centering Ethics: Finding a Path Forward in a Fragmented World
How does ethics shape the way we respond to the challenges of our time? Access this recording of Carnegie Council's Global Ethics Day 2026 flagship event.
Hosted by Asha Rangappa & Brian A. Mateo