Ethics & International Affairs Volume 20.4 (Winter 2006): Articles: Judicial Globalization in the Service of Self-Government [Abstract]

Nov 28, 2006

For at least the past several decades, judges around the world have been looking beyond their own states’ jurisprudence to international law and the decisions of foreign courts in order to apply domestic law. This widespread practice is part of a phenomenon that Anne-Marie Slaughter calls “judicial globalization.” The American judiciary, however, has exhibited a distinct diffidence toward the use of comparative and international law to decide domestic cases, a diffidence that extends to many elected officials as well. . . . Various defenses of the Supreme Court’s reliance on international and comparative sources have been made, not least by some of the Supreme Court justices themselves.

None of the defenses, however, have met the democratic objections head-on. Instead, justifications have mainly defended the general utility of referencing additional sources rather than the specific legitimacy of referencing sources from outside the U.S. legal system. The defenses to date fall short for at least two sets of reasons. They fail to grapple with legitimate concerns about the practice. In consequence, they offer no reasons for those opposed to this practice to reconsider their resistance.

To read or purchase the full text of this article, click here.

You may also like

Robert D. Kaplan & Stephen D. Hibbard. CREDIT: Simon Myaskovsky.

NOV 10, 2026 • Video

Getting China Right: The Ultimate Moral Dilemma

How can the U.S. avoid miscalculating when it comes to China? Access the Third Charles W. Kegley, Jr. Annual Lecture with Robert D. Kaplan.

NOV 6, 2026 • Podcast

Moral Courage, Individual Agency, and Institutional Trust

Former FBI special agent Asha Rangappa joins “Values & Interests” to discuss the ethical challenges facing public servants in an era of eroding institutional norms.

Clockwise: Nadav Avihay, Daniel A. Zarrilli, Janice Beecher, Rebecca Distler, Sylvana Q. Sinha, Jay Chaudhuri, Eleonore Fournier-Tombs, Molly Schaeffer, Jodi Vittori, Peter S. Goodman, Will Freeman, Joshua Acosta. CREDIT: Veronika Cernadas.

NOV 3, 2026 • Video

Carnegie Ethics Fellows Symposium 2026

Access expert panels on water ethics, AI in healthcare, economic and national security, and AI in humanitarian response, moderated by the Carnegie Ethics Fellows.

Not translated

This content has not yet been translated into your language. You can request a translation by clicking the button below.

Request Translation