Global Ethics Corner: Which Separatist Movements Will Succeed?

Dec 10, 2012

From Spain to Scotland to even the United States, separatist movements are making headlines. Do any of these have a chance to succeed? Or all they just for show?

They say breaking up is hard to do.

But peaceful national independence movements across the world have enjoyed a noticeable uptick in popularity and success over recent months.

In October, Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond and British Prime Minister David Cameron signed the so-called “Edinburgh Agreement,” which will put a single yes-or-no referendum on the independence question before Scottish voters by the end of 2014. Scotland has been a part of the United Kingdom since 1707.

In Spain’s Catalonia region, separatist political parties supporting either independence or greater autonomy from the rest of Spain won a majority of seats in last month’s regional parliamentary elections, paving the way for a referendum on independence. While Catalonia enjoyed a brief period of autonomy during the early 1930s, the region has been a part of a united Spain since 1716.

Perhaps most surprisingly, in the days following President Barack Obama’s November reelection, voters from all 50 American states started and signed petitions on the White House website asking to be allowed to peacefully secede from the United States. No one seriously expects the secession of an American state anytime soon. In fact, no state has seceded from the United States since Tennessee became the last of the Confederates to do so at the start of the American Civil War in 1861.

But the ballot-box successes of the Catalonian and Scottish independence movements could potentially hold valuable lessons for separatist movements from Quebec to the Caucasus and from Kurdistan to Chiapas.

Then again, perhaps seceding from a peaceful and relatively prosperous Western European nation is easier in the 21st century than it used to be.

What do you think? Do the separatists in Scotland, Spain, and the United States have any chance of succeeding in their quests for independence? Or is it all just for show?

Let us know.

For more infomration see

Ron Synovitz, "Reading the Elections in Catalonia: Will This Mean the End of Spain?," The Atlantic, November 27, 2012

Associated Press, "UN envoy: No settlement in sight for Western Sahara; will launch shuttle diplomacy round," The Washington Post, November 28, 2012

Photo credits in order of appearance: Brandon Christopher Warren Scottish Government [also for picture 3] Scottish Parliament Marc Sardon [also for picture 13] Txiki Trepax Vicente Rojo The White House [also for picture 9] Don Shall Nils Geylen Richardson and Cox Youssef Shoufan Oriana Eliçabe Ian Muir Jimmy Emerson

You may also like

MAY 13, 2022 Article

Ethics As We Know it is Gone. It's Time for Ethics Re-envisioned.

Given the troubling state of international affairs there is reason to be greatly concerned about how ethics is framed or co-opted. To meet this moment, ...

MAY 10, 2022 Podcast

Making Decisions When Values Conflict or Are Prioritized Differently, with Paul Root Wolpe

In this Artificial Intelligence & Equality podcast, Carnegie-Uehiro Fellow Wendell Wallach sits down with Emory University's Professor Paul Root Wolpe for a thought-provoking conversation about the ...

MAY 9, 2022 Podcast

Any Progress in Building Moral Machines? with Colin Allen

Much has been said about the inability of tech and AI developers to grapple with ethical theory and inherent tension. Similarly, philosophers are often criticized ...