Global Ethics Corner: The Power of Economic Models

Apr 22, 2011

Economic models were the basis for crucial practical decisions that led to the 2008-09 financial crisis. Yet government bailouts remain controversial because free market advocates see intervention as wrong. Do you agree with the need to manage markets? Or should the economy be guided only be the "invisible hand"?

Economic models become the basis for crucial practical decisions.

Models were at work in the 2008-09 financial crisis. Banks, automakers, and insurers were protected based on assumptions about economic consequences.

You cannot prove a negative. So we'll never be sure if President Obama's decisions prevented the Great Recession from turning into a second Great Depression.

The government bailouts remain controversial because free market advocates see intervention as wrong. Market models clashed with behavioral models. In hindsight, both seem inadequate.

John Authers in the Financial Times notes that "…economics' most basic assumption is flawed,"i.e. the idea that "all other things are equal," and markets are rational. This idea is behind the market model, and contends that, "Nobody has yet come up with a more efficient way to allocate capital than the market."

Authers continues, "Against this came the behaviouralists, who substituted the findings of behavioural psychology for the assumptions of rationality." These assumptions mandate "nudging" markets to correct for human bias and herd behavior.

Both sets of assumptions, market and behavioral, are just that, assumptions. Neither seems adequate. Authers suggests it's time "to break free from this debate and find a new way to model markets."

Yet, our perceptions lag far behind our economic challenges, and the dichotomy continues to animate political rhetoric.

What do you think? Do you accept the free market assumptions? Do you agree with behavioralism and the need to manage markets?

By William Vocke

For more information see:

John Authers, "We Need New Models in an Uncertain World," Financial Times, March 11, 2011.

Bhide, Amar. (2010). A Call for Judgment: Sensible Finance for a Dynamic Economy. New York: Oxford University Press

Frydman, Roman. & Goldberg, Michael D. (2011) Beyond Mechanical Markets: Asset Price Swings, Risk, and the Role of the State. Princeton: Princeton University Press

Photo Credits in order of Appearance:
Chiva Congelado
Mike McCune
Pete Souza
Public Citizen
EnergeticNYC
Richard Thaler & Cass Sunsteien

Brian Hillegas
RoGb77

You may also like

DEC 4, 2020 Podcast

The Doorstep: Opportunities for a New U.S. Policy Toward African Nations, with Ambassador Charles A. Ray

In this week's Doorstep, hosts Tatiana Serafin and Nikolas Gvosdev are joined by Charles A. Ray, current chair of the Foreign Policy Research Institute's Africa ...

NOV 13, 2020 Podcast

AI as a Tool for Workers' Empowerment, with Christina J. Colclough

Following up on the AI & Equality Initiative's first webinar on artificial intelligence and the future of work, Carnegie-Uehiro Fellow Wendell Wallach and Dr. Christina Colclough, ...

H&M Asia flagship store, Causeway Bay, Hong Kong. CREDIT: <a href=https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:H%26M_Flagship_store_in_HK_CWB_Exterior_201511.jpg>Wpcpey/Wikimedia</a> <a href=https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/deed.en>(CC)</a>

SEP 21, 2020 Article

Will Consumers Pay More To Not Source from China?

Retailer H&M will stop relying on Chinese garment factories and suppliers located in Xinjiang, over concerns about the use of Uyghers as forced labor. ...