Global Ethics Corner: Defeating Piracy

Mar 4, 2011

In March 2011, there were over 50 vessels and 800 people held hostage by Somali pirates. What should be the response to these captures? Should a third party attack, negotiate, seek legal remedies, or continue to make the best of a terrible situation?

In March 2011, there were over 50 vessels and 800 people held hostage by Somali pirates.

Normally hostages and vessels are ransomed. Pirates have extorted over $100 million.

The situation is ideal for extortion. The window for decisive action is narrow. Current international law allows pirates to be arrested only when caught in the act. Once pirated, the crews' lives, the cargo, and the vessel are at risk if rescue is attempted.

A long-term revision of international law may allow arrests for cruising far offshore with weapons, lots of fuel, and limited fishing capacity.

But in the short-term, why not imitate Jefferson's successful action with the Barbary Pirates in 1801: blockade and attack their bases? This seems untenable given American engagements elsewhere; the diffuse, amoeba-like structure of pirate organizations; and the failed Somali state.

Staging rescues, treating pirates individually as hostile combatants, and attacking cruisers might eliminate piracy.

Piracy, however, is also a business model and would diminish if costs outweighed rewards. Owners' have preferred to pay ransom and higher insurance rates, waiting an average six months to get crews and vessels back.

The ethical questions are clear. Who has the right to risk the lives of innocent crews? Should inactive cruisers be assumed innocent? Should international law evolve to adapt to new circumstances?

What would you do? Attack, negotiate, seek legal remedies, or continue to make the best of a terrible situation?

By William Vocke

For more information see:

Jeffery Gettleman, "Suddenly, a Rise in Piracy's Price," The New York Times, February 26, 2011.

Photo Credits in order of Appearance:

Jason R. Zalasky/ U.S. Navy

RubyGoes
Eric L. Beauregard/ U.S. Navy
Eric L. Beauregard/ U.S. Navy
Eric L. Beauregard/ U.S. Navy
Jason R. Zalasky/ U.S. Navy
Charles Waterhouse/ U.S. Marines
Cassandra Thompson/ U.S. Navy
Jason R. Zalasky/ U.S. Navy
Michael Sandberg/ U.S. Navy
Jason R. Zalasky/ U.S. Navy
Bart Bauer/ U.S. Navy
Michael Junge/ U.S. Navy

You may also like

FEB 7, 2025 Podcast

Values & Interests: Trailer to the Series

Values & Interests is a new podcast from Carnegie Council, which takes a deep dive into the ethical tensions and tradeoffs at the heart of decision-making ...

FEB 7, 2025 Article

Ethical Considerations for the Future of Artificial Intelligence in Education (AIED) and Healthcare

Artificial intelligence (AI) has the potential to revolutionize healthcare and education. This final project from the first CEF cohort explores the ethical implications of these ...

FEB 6, 2025 Article

A Moment for Moral Resilience—Not Exhaustion

Humanitarianism, international cooperation, and democracy are being challenged and outright rejected. But we need moral resilience to help us navigate this complicated time.

Not translated

This content has not yet been translated into your language. You can request a translation by clicking the button below.

Request Translation