Global Ethics Corner: Who Dies in Afghanistan: Soldiers, Civilians, or the Mission?

Jul 16, 2010

How do you choose missions to fight a war effectively, while minimizing civilian deaths and meeting the obligation to your soldiers?

When states or movements go to war, people die.

There is no bigger ethical choice than choosing to risk lives. There should be a moral purpose behind a decision to fight. In Afghanistan in 2003, with the Taliban sheltering al Qaeda and September 11th a recent memory, the moral purpose was clear. In the 2010 policy debate, for many that certainty is harder to find.

Perhaps more important, however, are the choices involved while fighting. Three competing demands must be balanced. These are amplified in a non-conventional war like Afghanistan, where a counter-insurgency strategy places them in sharp contrast.

First, young combatants are conscripted or volunteer to fight, and perhaps die. There is an ethical requirement to provide them with their best chance to survive.

Next, non-combatants rightly expect not to be targets, but separating civilians from combatants in Afghanistan is difficult. Nevertheless, there is an ethical requirement to keep them safe.

Finally, battles must be fought, and when choosing missions there is usually a tension between implementing the strategy and risking soldiers or civilians.

Balancing these three competing demands can be a vicious circle. Emphasizing mission puts winning first. But in Afghanistan, killing civilians jeopardizes the mission. Rules of engagement for soldiers that try to limit civilian deaths increase soldiers' risks.

What would you do? How do you choose missions to fight a war effectively, while minimizing civilian deaths and meeting the obligation to your soldiers?

By William Vocke

Photo Credits in order of Appearance:

Andrya Hill/ US Army
Mark O'Donald/ US Army
Rick Scavetta/ US Army
Paz Quillé, Canadian Forces Combat Camera
Craig Fiander, JTF
Rahmudeen Nangarhari
Jennifer Cohen
Robin Mugridge

You may also like

AUG 19, 2021 Podcast

The Doorstep: The Future of Afghanistan Roundtable Discussion, with Ali M Latifi & Said Sabir Ibrahimi

Ali M Latifi, Kabul-based journalist for Al Jazeera English, and Said Sabir Ibrahimi, non-resident fellow with NYU's Center on International Cooperation, join "Doorstep" co-hosts Nick ...

United States President James Monroe presides over a cabinet meeting, 1823. CREDIT: <a href="">Granger Historical Picture Archive/Wikimedia</a> <a href="">(Public Domain)</a>

MAR 30, 2021 Article

Learning (Ethical) Lessons from the Greek Revolution

In this blog post, U.S. Global Engagement Senior Fellow Nikolas Gvosdev reacts to an article from Paul Glastris in the "Washington Monthly." Nearly 200 years ...

U.S. Deputy Secretary of State Antony Blinken &  Vice President Joe Biden in Honolulu, July 2016. CREDIT: <a href="">Staff Sgt. Chris Hubenthal/U.S.Department of Defense</a>/<a href="">Public Domain</a>

NOV 23, 2020 Article

Competing Ethics in the Biden Administration?

In this blog post responding to Thomas Wright's recent article in "The Atlantic," Senior Fellow Nikolas Gvosdev outlines the three different "camps" vying for influence ...