Can You Ever Earn Too Much?

Nov 20, 2009

Within society there seems to be a general public disdain for excess and a private commitment to excess. Should there be formal or informal standards for compensation? Can you ever earn too much?

The clash between private and public good can be bipolar.

A headline reads, "Some Wall Street Year-End Bonuses Could Hit Pre-Downturn Highs," and the story notes that "Main Street is ticked off that Wall Street is making all this money."

Privately, when individuals get the legal chance to earn more, few say, "No, pay me less." Taking a hit for the greater good seems old-fashioned, naïve. Most are eager to earn more, if only to give to their favorite non-profit.

Publicly, Wall Street is pummeled for outrageous salaries, executives at corporations taking taxpayer bailouts are pilloried for bilking the public, and Congress pursues new laws to prevent excess compensation.

For companies which didn't get federal dollars is compensation a private matter? If a company downsizes 1,000 people and profits go up, shouldn't the leadership be rewarded?

Should people be embarrassed or jubilant about huge personal incomes, or just thankful to be one of the lucky few? Is the point opportunity and the chance to succeed, is the point a shared society and joint sacrifice, or can it be both?

There seems is a disconnect, a general public disdain for excess, and a private commitment to excess.

Meanwhile, societal norms and expectations of behavior that would curb excess seem diminished. Without a commitment to joint sacrifice, society is left with shouting commentators, narrow legislation, and individual decisions.

What do you think? Should there be formal or informal standards for compensation? Can you ever earn too much?

By William Vocke

For more information, see: Eric Dash, "Some Wall Street Year-End Bonuses Could Hit Pre-Downturn Highs," The New York Times, November 5, 2009, p. B3.

You may also like

MAY 6, 2022 Podcast

For Companies, Could China Be the Next Russia? with Perth Tolle

After Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the global financial backlash was swift and unprecedented: Dozens of financial institutions cut off their exposure to the Russian market ...

JUL 10, 2019 Podcast

Ethics in Business: In Their Own Words, with Pendal's Emilio Gonzalez

Emilio Gonzalez, group CEO at Pendal in Australia, speaks about the role of ethics in global investment management. He discusses his organization's charitable work, its ...

JUL 10, 2019 Video

Ethics in Business: In Their Own Words, with Pendal's Emilio Gonzalez

Emilio Gonzalez, group CEO at Pendal in Australia, speaks about the role of ethics in global investment management. He discusses his organization's charitable work, its ...