Global Ethics Corner: When You Cross a Line

Oct 30, 2009

When balancing life's complex tensions, how do you know when you've crossed a line?

Life's tensions preoccupy a wonderful Taiwanese film, which demands we consider choices.

A professional tension shows in the title, "No Puedo Vivir Sin Ti," Spanish which captures perfectly the Taiwanese. The English, "I Can't Live without You," sounds too much like a love ballad, but there is no Spanish in the movie. Marketing device or artistic insight?

The film is about breaking and rescuing lives. A middle-aged man, Li Wu-hisung, does odd jobs at the port and lives with his daughter, Mei, in illegal housing. The two survive fairly happily, but the household is unregistered, and she should enter school. Helping Mei compromises them.

One tension is facing these small, daily tragedies. Will they loose each other? The rules exist for humane reasons. The bureaucrats personally have empathy. Should they bend or break the rules? Conversely, could their compassion become corruption?

Another tension regards risks that individuals or society assume. Li dives into the harbor's depths to repair ships, knowing his employer is careless. What of Mei if he doesn’t work, but what if Li dies? He has free universal healthcare, but no safety regulations. What are they owed, and what responsibility is his?

Finally Li endangers Mei in a desperate act. Does love and oppression justify this desperation? Also, what price must he pay?

The filmmakers' answers to tension are complex, a balance of both sides of the line.

What do you think? Can you balance these tensions or must you choose? When do you cross a line?

By William Vocke

You may also like

MAR 15, 2022 Podcast

The Strategy of Denial: American Defense in an Age of Great Power Conflict, with Elbridge Colby

In this wide-ranging talk, U.S. defense expert Elbridge Colby discusses the changing nature of American power with Carnegie Council President Joel Rosenthal. As the ...

Italian navy rescues asylum seekers in the Mediterranean off the coast of Africa, June 2014. <br>CREDIT: <a href="">Massimo Sestini/Polaris</a> <a href="">(CC)</a>.

JUN 20, 2021 Article

The World's Refugee System Needs to be Made Responsible

Today, we are faced with an unfair and ultimately unsustainable refugee system that simultaneously increases human suffering while placing the burden of hosting refugees on ...

PPE & COVID-19 testing kits arrive in the Philippines from China, March 2020. <br>CREDIT: <a href=>Philippines Presidential Communications Operations Office/Wikimedia (CC)</a>.

JUL 28, 2020 Article

Ethical Dilemmas in Ensuring Human Security

In this blog post, Carnegie Council Senior Fellow Nikolas Gvosdev reflects on his recent "Human Security is National Security in a Time of Pandemic" webinar ...