Markets or Regulations, Is That the Question?

Jul 31, 2009

Should government supplement markets to increase the public good? Should it regulate markets to protect the public good? How much is too much regulation?

How much should governments be involved in creating or countering the indirect consequences of markets?

Should government supplement markets to increase the public good? Think navigating the Mississippi or interstate highways.

Should government regulate markets to protect the public good? Think insured saving accounts and food safety inspections.

Before World War I, Progressives argued against monopolies and unsupervised meatpacking plants. These produced negative consequences for consumers, but regulation added limits to markets and added costs.

If you create a product and dump toxic waste, government needs to impose a cost, which changes the price or the behavior.

Ian Bremmer notes that pricing financial consequences is hard to understand, as is the appropriate governmental regulation. What do CDOs, collateralized debt obligations, mean in terms of unemployment or people's homes?

Regulation is where reasonable people disagree. Over the last decades, the U.S. had a proactive, fairly conservative ideological bent toward protecting financial producers, not consumers.

What do you think? Should that change? Does regulation simply close the barn doors? How much regulation is too much?

By William Vocke. Portions adapted from Ian Bremmer, "Interview: Grave New World of Politics and Finance," Stocks, Futures and Options Magazine, July 2009, 14-22.

To post a comment, go to the Global Ethics Corner slideshow.

You may also like

MAR 29, 2023 Podcast

Reframing the Refugee Crisis, with Sana Mustafa

In collaboration with Marymount Manhattan College and their Social Justice Academy: Great Migrations, "Doorstep" co-host Tatiana Serafin speaks with Sana Mustafa, CEO of Asylum Access, ...

MAR 27, 2023 Podcast

C2GTalk: How should policymakers address the risk of climate tipping points? with Jo Tyndall

Climate tipping points are points of no return, beyond which the Earth's systems would reorganize beyond the capacity of socioeconomic and ecological systems to adapt, ...

MAR 22, 2023 Podcast

How Feminist Foreign Policy Can Reshape the Globe, with Kristina Lunz

In the second conversation of our Women's History Month podcast series, Kristina Lunz, co-CEO and co-founder of the Centre for Feminist Foreign Policy, joins "Doorstep" ...