Global Ethics Corner: When Are Elections Legitimate?

Jun 19, 2009

When are elections legitimate? What about Iran? Elections assume that losers accept results. Because many disagree, can they overturn an election? Should we believe authorities that declare elections valid?

When are elections legitimate? What about Iran?

Because many disagree, can they overturn an election? Should we believe an authority that declares an election valid?

In 1876, Hayes not Tilden, and in 2000, Bush not Gore, became Presidents in questionable circumstances. Controversy was extensive. However, both governed legitimately.

The 2002 Algerian election, won by the Islamist, National Liberation Front, was quickly overturned by the military under the belief that the Front was committed to "one person, one vote, only one time."

The 2008 Minnesota Senatorial contest may take a year to resolve. How?

Legitimacy rests on two interrelated ideas. One is transparency. Florida had legions from both sides looking at every hanging chad on every punched ballot. Openness is key to transforming autocratic decisions into legitimate results.

Another is process. A process must be agreed to by the players and perceived as fair through all four stages: candidate selection, campaign, voting, and appeals.

From outside, neither openness nor redress seems to apply in Iran.

What do you think? Should the Iranian losers reject the outcome? Did they lose? Is the Iranian election legitimate?

By William Vocke

To post a comment, go to the Global Ethics Corner slideshow.

You may also like

APR 6, 2021 Article

Are Americans Facing an Undemocratic Future?

Faith in democracy is waning, and the events of the past year have done little to inspire confidence. Today, the presumption of democracy as an ...

Terreiro do Pa├žo, Lisbon, Portugal, June 6, 2020. CREDIT: <a href="">Anita Braga (CC)</a>.

SEP 14, 2020 Transcript

Protests in Perspective: The Protests Go Global, with Mary L. Dudziak & Brenda Gayle Plummer

The killing of George Floyd and the wave of protests that followed bring to life the current struggle for civil rights, human rights, and social ...

CREDIT: <a href="">Tvabutzku1234 (CC)</a>

FEB 11, 2020 Article

Gallagher's Proposal & Emerging Narratives

Rep. Michael Gallagher (R-WI) recently penned a "Wall Street Journal" op-ed laying out a new paradigm for U.S. foreign policy, as it relates to ...