Global Ethics Corner: Is the Free Market Central to America's Future?

May 15, 2009

New York is no longer viewed as the financial capital of the world, or even of the United States. Given the recent government intervention in states' economies, will the free-market model be able to compete?

In Foreign Affairs, Ian Bremmer states, "Until very recently New York City was the world's financial capital. It no longer is even the financial capital of the United States. That distinction now falls to Washington..."

Most Americans see this government intervention as necessary, and many hope that this intervention will ebb as the economy rebounds. Some also see this as an opportunity to redress health care, income distribution, or environment issues.

First, should state capitalism in America exit as soon as possible? George Will's op-ed states it should but unfortunately won't.

Second, Bremmer sees this tide of intervention in the developing world as "signaling a strategic rejection of free-market doctrine." "(T)he free-market tide has now receded." "(S)tate capitalism has introduced massive inefficiencies into global markets and injected populist politics..."

Therefore, the underlying dynamic for the next decade will be the competition between state capitalism, particularly of China and Russia, and free-market models led by Western companies and the US.

So, will state capitalism dominate the developing world?

What do you think? One, will Washington recede? Two, can the western model compete? Three, should we worry?

By William Vocke, citing Ian Bremmer, "State Capitalism Comes of Age: The End of the Free Market?" Foreign Affairs (May/June 2009) and George Will, "Capitalism Goes Out of Tune," The Washington Post

To post a comment, go to the Global Ethics Corner slideshow.

You may also like

OCT 6, 2022 Podcast

AI for Information Accessibility: Ethics & Philosophy, with Emad Mousavi & Paolo Verdini

In this episode of the "AI for Information Accessibility" podcast, host Ayushi Khemka talks to Emad Mousavi and Paolo Verdini, both Ph.D. students at ...

OCT 5, 2022 Podcast

Is Elon Musk the Future of U.S. Foreign Policy? with Puck's Teddy Schleifer

With one tweet about the outlines of a peace deal between Ukraine and Russia, Elon Musk elicited a derisive response from Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, ...

OCT 4, 2022 Podcast

Ethics in the Classroom: Empowering the Next Generation

This panel brings together contributors from the Carnegie Council’s journal "Ethics & International Affairs" to explore how ethics can be used in the classroom to ...