Ethics & International Affairs Volume 20.2 (Summer 2006): Book Reviews: Beyond Justice: The Auschwitz Trial [Excerpt]

Jul 28, 2006

Jeffrey K. Olick, reviewer

What is the proper role for courts of law in confronting mass crimes? On the one hand, a justice system impotent to confront genocide and historical atrocities is hardly worth the name. On the other hand, the ‘‘rule of law’’ is valuable precisely because it restricts our desire for vengeance, even when it is well founded; democratic law can hold individuals accountable only for their acts, not for the system of which their acts are a part. There has been a long discourse on these issues over the years, and there have been legitimate arguments on both sides. Nevertheless, the exercise is never purely theoretical, and it is important to take into account who is making the argument, in what context, and for what reasons. Rebecca Wittmann’s monograph, Beyond Justice, is a detailed analysis of one of the most complex and consequential such legal confrontations with the perpetrators of genocide…

To read or purchase the full text of this article, click here.

You may also like

SEP 18, 2026 Podcast

A New Breed of American Oligarch

Casey Michel examines how concentrated wealth is reshaping American democracy and foreign policy, and the consequences when private interests take precedence over the public good.

Carnegie Ethics Fellows visit Golden Gate Bridge. CREDIT: Must See Tours.

SEP 15, 2026 Article

Building the Next Generation of Ethical Leaders

At a time of profound ethical challenges—from rapid technological change to shifting geopolitical tensions—Carnegie Council is helping prepare the next generation of leaders.

Joel Rosenthal and Jamie Fly

SEP 15, 2026 Video

Democracy as a Moral Principle

Access a recording of this "Values & Interests" event with Freedom House CEO Jamie Fly and Council President Joel Rosenthal discussing the state of democracy globally.

Not translated

This content has not yet been translated into your language. You can request a translation by clicking the button below.

Request Translation