Global Ethics Corner: Why Is Health Care So Difficult?

Jul 3, 2009

Why can't the U.S. negotiate a domestic solution to health care? Individuals are certainly responsible for their health. A wealthy society can also be responsible for its members. Is health care a primary right, or a personal responsibility?

Adequate health care is often seen as a right.

One international covenant asserts the right of everyone to "the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health."

Why can't the U.S. negotiate a domestic solution? The principle is clear; the devil is in the details.

Four dimensions are debated extensively: costs, levels of care, policies, and profits. However, the central issue is an ethical one: personal responsibility versus social responsibility. Both are important, but which is primary?

Charges echo of elitist versus populist, of indifference versus socialistic. These debates have long roots in America, over universal free public education, social security, gun ownership, or fluoridation of water.

Health care solutions are not impossible. Taiwan's adamantly free-market democracy with half of America's GDP per capita solved most of the details. Its system provides extensive patient choice, costs fractions of the U.S. system, extends the highest levels of care, emphasizes technology, and covers everyone.

Individuals are certainly responsible for their health. A wealthy society can also be responsible for its members.

What do you think? Is health care a primary right, or a personal responsibility?

By William Vocke

To post a comment, go to the Global Ethics Corner slideshow.

You may also like

MAY 3, 2022 Article

Why Democracy vs. Autocracy Misses the Point

Today, the world seems to be laser-focused on the struggle of "democracy vs. autocracy," but what if this ideological debate is missing the point? Columbia ...

Black Lives Matter protest in Columbus, Ohio, May 30, 2020. CREDIT: <A href=https://www.flickr.com/photos/21426642@N07/49954069361>Becker1999</a> <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/">(CC)</a>.

JUL 1, 2020 Article

Where Do Human Rights Fit In? Policy Narratives Re-examined

Senior Fellow Nikolas Gvosdev discusses Nahal Toosi's recent "Politico" article about a subtle but major shift in the international landscape: human rights groups focusing on ...

Inauguration of President Abraham Lincoln, March 4, 1861. CREDIT: <a href=https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Abraham_Lincoln_inauguration_1861.jpg>Library of Congress (CC)</a>.

MAY 8, 2020 Podcast

Democracy on the Verge: Leadership in Times of Crisis, with Ted Widmer

In this fascinating conversation with Carnegie Council President Joel Rosenthal, historian Ted Widmer looks back on 13 pivotal days in Abraham Lincoln's life in 1861--the basis ...