Global Ethics Corner: For Torture, Who Should We Prosecute?

Apr 24, 2009

Torture is wrong. So who is culpable? The point people? The memo writers? The overseers? No one? Everyone?

Torture is wrong. Who is culpable?

Jurisprudence tries to define torture; but institutions and lawyers can split hairs. The distinctions aren't just legal. They are important if you're the intended victim or subject to prosecution.

Nevertheless, at some point no one disagrees; water-boarding qualifies.

We'll sidestep a debate about relative harm. Does saving thousands justify torturing one? Or fifty? We'll assert that torture is always wrong. So who do we prosecute?

The Contractors, who pushed for aggressive techniques?

The CIA officers, who interrogated?

The Justice Department lawyers, who drafted detailed memos?

The senior cabinet, who approved recommendations?

The President, who signed off?

Congress and the public, who didn't intervene?

Some followed their best legal advice. Some were driven by the threat. Some were ignorant of details. Some pursued the greater good.

Some followed political expediency. Few ask about the history. The effectiveness was debatable.

Historically both the makers and the implementers of policy were held liable, as in World War II or the Balkans.

Obama says the key point isn't past prosecution but the future.

What do you think? Who's culpable? The point people? The memo writers? The overseers? No one? Everyone?

By William Vocke

To post a comment, go to the Global Ethics Corner slideshow.

You may also like

OCT 4, 2022 Podcast

Ethics in the Classroom: Empowering the Next Generation

This panel brings together contributors from the Carnegie Council’s journal "Ethics & International Affairs" to explore how ethics can be used in the classroom to ...

NOV 2, 2021 Video

Carnegie New Leaders Podcast: International Relations in the Context of Plato, with Ilya Kursenko

Samantha Jordan, president of Carnegie New Leaders, speaks with Ilya Kursenko, a member of the Carnegie New Leaders and a Master's student at Saint Petersburg ...

MAR 23, 2021 Podcast

Global Ethics Review: COVID-19 & International Relations, Part Two

In this new podcast series, we'll be connecting Carnegie Council's work and current events with our senior fellows, senior staff, and friends of our organization. ...

Not translated

This content has not yet been translated into your language. You can request a translation by clicking the button below.

Request Translation