Global Ethics Corner: Top Risks and Ethical Decisions

Jan 23, 2009

What is true for the individual may not be true for the group, the state, or the international system, and vice versa. Does this suggest that ethics is personal, not institutional or governmental? For you, at what levels does ethical choice live?

There is a difference between the top risks facing the world in 2009 and the underlying ethical dilemmas, but articulating that difference is difficult.

Eurasia Group's list of ten top 2009 political risks begins: 1) the U.S. Congress, 2) South Asia Security, and 3) Iran/Israel. This is geopolitics, not ethics.

However, developing or deploying nuclear weapons in South Asia or Iran involves ethical issues at four levels, i.e.: Does adding a nuclear state make the system more likely to implode? Is Iranian leadership more secure with nuclear weapons? What is Islam’s interpretation? As a technician do I participate in the nuclear program?

International relations theory distinguishes these as "levels of analysis." What is true for the individual may not be true for the group, the state, or the international system, and vice versa.

Art Kleiner, editor of Strategy+Business, suggests that risks have to be approached by the individual leader. Making ethical choices regarding risks require each person to exhibit a combination of empathy, conscience, and discipline.

Does this suggest that ethics is personal, not institutional or governmental? For you, at what levels does ethical choice live?

Adapted by William Vocke from a Workshops for Ethics in Business panel discussion

To post a comment, go to the Global Ethics Corner slideshow.

You may also like

DEC 7, 2022 Article

Five Moments That Will Shape Ethics in International Affairs for 2023

How can ethics help us better understand the world in 2023 and the choices we face within it? Carnegie Council President Joel Rosenthal discusses the FTX ...

Shanghai skyline

FEB 22, 2022 Podcast

Media Engagement in China: A Series of Ethical Questions

In the 1950s, Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev bemoaned that the United States wouldn’t even sell buttons to the Soviet Union. "Buttons can hold up ...

MAY 26, 2021 Podcast

Creative Reflections on the History & Role of AI Ethics, with Wendell Wallach

How is the new global digital economy taking form? What are the trade-offs? Who are the stakeholders? How do we build “participatory intelligence”? In this ...

Not translated

This content has not yet been translated into your language. You can request a translation by clicking the button below.

Request Translation