Carnegie Council

Text Size: A A

Articles

Cultural Sources of Human Rights in East Asia: Consensus Building Toward a Rights Regime 06/05/96
Examining "cultural sources" is not about seeing whether Eastern cultural traditions fit with the concept of human rights as understood in the West, but rather of an "unforced consensus," expanding an area of consensus on norms while allowing room for disagreement.

Author(s): Joanne Bauer

The Validity of a Cultural Approach to Human Rights 06/05/96
Culture is an integral part of any human rights question. Workshop participants examined human rights practices in different East Asian contexts and their convergence and divergence from international standards.

A Proposal for an "Unforced Consensus" 06/05/96
How do we go about identifying cultural norms from which we can begin to develop an "unforced consensus" on human rights that is sensitive to varying cultural norms?

Sources of Human Rights in Asian Cultures 06/05/96
The Buddhist duty of avihimsa (nonviolence); the importance Islam places on umma (community) and equality before God; and Confucian ren (humanity) each lead to ethical norms that can form the basis of human rights.

Textual Interpretation 06/05/96
Textual interpretation, when applied to cultural sources of human rights, becomes a question of power. Who interprets these texts? Who decides whether the interpretations are legitimate or deviant? The answer directly affects the lives of human beings.

Building on the Existing International Human Rights Regime 06/05/96
Even as they seek to construct a framework that takes into account non-Western cultures, both Onuma's intercivilizational approach and An-Na im's "cultural mediation" of human rights build upon, rather than reject, existing international standards.
Author(s): Onuma Yasuaki

Conclusion: Asian Contributions to Human Rights 06/05/96
Proposals for widening consensus on norms will be of little value if mechanisms are not in place to enforce compliance. Time constraints at the workshop allowed only superficial treatment of this topic, addressed at the next workshop, in October 1996.

About Human Rights Dialogue

Human Rights Dialogue promotes a global discussion of human rights ideas and practices by presenting firsthand accounts of human rights issues as they arise within specific real-life contexts. In so doing, it helps to clarify the significant and ongoing evolution that is taking place within the human rights movement to make the human rights framework more relevant and effective in addressing the social, economic, and political challenges of the twenty-first century.

The entire publication is online, or you may purchase individual print copies.

Series One (1993–1998)examines all sides of the Asian values debate—the argument that Asian cultural values imply different human rights standards and priorities from those in the West.

Series Two(2000–2005)addresses the problem of the “human rights box”—the constraints that have enabled the human rights framework to gain currency among elites while limiting its advance among the most vulnerable. Specifically, the essays aim to locate the barriers to greater public legitimacy of human rights and to demonstrate how those barriers can be overcome.