Carnegie Council

Shopping Cart

People Topics

Text Size: A A

Print this Page Email this Page Bookmark and Share

Ethics and Emigration: The East German Exodus, 1989 (Case Study #6)

(1990)

Thomas M. Magstadt

Ethics and Emigration: The East German Exodus, 1989
Ethics and Emigration: The East German Exodus, 1989
In the fall of 1989, thousands of East Germans defied Prime Minister Erich Honecker and his regime's ban on unauthorized departure from the German Democratic Republic (GDR), and escaped to West Germany through Hungary, Poland, and even Czechoslovakia.

This spontaneous mass exodus occurred despite a relatively liberal emigration and travel policy in effect at the time. In 1989 alone the GDR was planning to give some 100,000 East Germans permission to leave permanently, compared to fewer than 30,000 in 1988 and about 10,000 in 1989. In September and October of 1989, some 55,000-60,000 East Germans fled without permission. Ironically, the Berlin Wall came down at that time for precisely the same reason that it had been put up: to stop the hemorrhaging that threatened the regime's very survival and to keep its people in.

The East German revolt of 1989 thus raised a variety of policy-relevant ethical issues. What does it mean to be a citizen in the absence of choice? How does this relate to prevailing notions of human rights? What can and should nations do to promote "the freedom of movement"? If it is incumbent on all governments to grant their own citizens the right to leave, do governments not also have a moral responsibility to give all citizens, irrespective of national origin, a place to go?

To purchase this case study, go to the GUISD Pew Case Study Center.

Read More: Human RightsMigration, , Germany


About The Case Studies Series

The Carnegie Council offers this series of 22 case studies for use in college and university classrooms. Each case presents and analyzes an historical example of an ethical dilemma in international affairs.

Features

Policy Innovations Online Magazine

The central address for a fairer globalization.
» More

blue dot separator

Ethics & International Affairs

Go to the Journal for articles on ethics and foreign policy.
» More